This content is for educational purposes only and is not financial or investment advice. Precious metals prices fluctuate; past performance does not guarantee future results. Consult a qualified professional before making investment decisions.
Tap the image to enlarge and zoom.Hover to magnify, or click to open full screen.
When you are searching for local gold silver buyers hallmarks are one of the first things a reputable dealer will check – and understanding what those marks mean puts you in a much stronger position before you walk through any door. Whether you have a drawer full of old jewelry, a small collection of silver coins, or a gold bar you inherited, knowing how buyers evaluate precious metals helps you get a fair offer and avoid leaving money on the table.
This guide covers how hallmarks influence pricing, how melt value is calculated, what separates a trustworthy local buyer from a mediocre one, and why Accurate Precious Metals in Salem, Oregon stands out whether you are local or shipping from across the country.
What Hallmarks Actually Tell a Buyer
A hallmark is a stamp pressed into a piece of metal that communicates purity, maker, or country of origin. For gold jewelry, you will typically see marks like 10K, 14K, 18K, or 22K. European pieces often use decimal equivalents: 585 for 14K, 750 for 18K. For silver, common marks include Sterling, 925, 900, or .999.
These numbers translate directly to metal content. A 14K gold ring is 58.5% pure gold. A sterling silver bracelet is 92.5% pure silver. The closer to pure metal, the closer the item sits to full melt value.
Hallmarks save time. A buyer can glance at a stamp and form a starting estimate before any testing begins. But hallmarks do not replace testing. Marks can be worn down, incorrectly stamped, or in rare cases faked. A serious buyer always confirms with acid testing, electronic testing, or XRF analysis before making an offer. If a buyer quotes you a price without checking the metal at all, that is a red flag.
How Melt Value Is Calculated
Melt value is the raw worth of the metal content, nothing more. The formula is straightforward:
melt value = spot price x troy ounces x purity
At the time of writing, gold is trading at approximately $4,353 per troy ounce and silver at approximately $72 per troy ounce. Use those as your baseline.
A practical example: a 14K gold chain weighing 10 grams. First, convert grams to troy ounces – 10 grams is about 0.322 troy ounces. Then multiply by purity: 0.322 x 0.585 = 0.188 troy ounces of actual gold. Multiply that by the spot price: 0.188 x $4,353 ≈ $819 in pure gold content at the time of writing. A buyer will offer less than that to cover their costs, but that number gives you a floor to work from.
For silver, a one-ounce .999 fine silver round is worth roughly $72 at the time of writing before any dealer spread. A sterling silver spoon weighing one troy ounce contains 0.925 ounces of pure silver, so its melt value is closer to $66.60.
Knowing these numbers before you visit a buyer means you can quickly sense whether an offer is reasonable or suspiciously low.
Common Gold and Silver Hallmarks at a Glance
Hallmark
Metal
Purity
10K
Gold
41.7%
14K / 585
Gold
58.5%
18K / 750
Gold
75.0%
22K
Gold
91.7%
24K / .999
Gold
99.9%
Sterling / 925
Silver
92.5%
900
Silver
90.0%
800
Silver
80.0%
.999
Silver
99.9%
These marks are the foundation of every offer calculation. The higher the purity, the larger the fraction of spot price you are entitled to receive. A piece marked .999 fine is essentially worth full spot minus dealer margin. A piece marked 10K is worth less than half of spot per gram.
Where Local Buyers Fit Best
Not every buyer is right for every item. A pawn shop might be convenient for quick cash on scrap jewelry, but it may not recognize the numismatic value of a key-date coin. A specialist coin dealer might pay well above melt for a rare Morgan dollar but have little interest in a broken gold necklace.
Matching Your Item to the Right Buyer
1
Scrap jewelry or broken gold Take it to a gold buyer or bullion dealer with in-house testing. Speed and payout are the priorities here.
2
Bullion bars and rounds A bullion dealer or coin shop familiar with market pricing is your best bet. They know the difference between a generic round and a recognized brand like Engelhard.
3
Common circulated coins A coin shop can quickly separate melt value from collector value. Do not let a non-specialist melt a coin that might be worth more whole.
4
Rare or graded coins Seek a coin specialist or NGC/PCGS authorized dealer who can assess condition, mint mark, and variety before pricing.
5
Mixed estate lots An appraiser or estate jewelry buyer can sort metal, stones, and collectibles rather than lumping everything together at scrap rates.
For anyone selling coins, it is worth reading up on how selling your gold online compares to in-person options – the answer often depends on the type of item and how much you value convenience versus maximum payout.
Local Buyers vs. Mail-In Services
The traditional path is walking into a shop, handing over your items, and leaving with cash. That works well when you are local and want immediate answers. But it has limits – you are restricted to whatever buyers operate near you, and offer quality varies widely.
Mail-in services have changed the equation. A reputable dealer with a nationwide mail-in program can reach sellers anywhere in the country, often with competitive offers that reflect live spot prices rather than the thinner margins of a small local shop.
Local Buyer vs. Mail-In Service
Pros
✓ Local buyer: immediate in-person offer and same-day payment
✓ Local buyer: you can watch testing happen in real time
✓ Local buyer: good for building a long-term relationship with a dealer
✓ Mail-in service: access to dealers with broader expertise and better pricing infrastructure
✓ Mail-in service: insured shipping protects your items in transit
✓ Mail-in service: works for anyone in the US, regardless of location
Cons
✗ Local buyer: limited to shops in your geographic area
✗ Local buyer: offer quality depends heavily on which shop you walk into
✗ Mail-in service: payment takes a few days rather than minutes
The practical answer: if you are in Salem, Oregon or nearby, visiting in person is fast and easy. If you are in Texas, Utah, or anywhere else in the country, a well-established mail-in service is often the smarter move. Accurate Precious Metals serves both groups – learn more about selling gold and silver in Texas or selling in Utah if you are in those areas.
Four Steps to Getting the Best Offer
How to Sell Gold and Silver Confidently
1
Step 1 – Verify your hallmarks Before you go anywhere, look at each item under good light. Note every stamp you can find. 10K, 14K, 18K, 925, Sterling – write them down. If marks are worn or missing, a buyer will still test the metal, but knowing your marks in advance helps you follow the conversation.
2
Step 2 – Weigh your items A kitchen scale that measures in grams is enough. You do not need precision laboratory equipment. A rough weight gives you a starting estimate so you can check whether a buyer’s numbers make sense.
3
Step 3 – Compare at least two offers One offer is not a market. Get at least two. Offers can vary by 10% or more depending on the buyer’s overhead, expertise, and whether they recognize collector value. For coins especially, the difference between a melt offer and a numismatic offer can be substantial.
4
Step 4 – Ask how the offer was calculated A trustworthy buyer will explain the weight and purity they used. If a buyer cannot or will not explain the basics of their offer, walk away.
💡 Tip: Do not rush. A buyer who pressures you to decide on the spot may not have your best interests in mind. A fair offer holds for a reasonable amount of time.
What Collectors Need to Know Before Selling
This section matters more than most sellers realize. Selling a collectible coin as scrap is one of the most common and costly mistakes in the precious metals market.
A coin’s melt value is its floor, not its ceiling. A 1921 Morgan Silver Dollar contains about 0.7734 troy ounces of 90% silver – roughly $50 in silver content at the time of writing. But depending on mint mark, date, and condition, that same coin might sell for $35, $75, or several hundred dollars to a collector. Melting it captures only the lowest possible value.
Key dates, proof coins, graded examples, and coins with strong eye appeal all carry premiums that a scrap buyer will not pay. A coin shop or NGC-authorized dealer is the right destination for anything that might have numismatic significance. Accurate Precious Metals is an NGC Authorized dealer, which means the team can assess whether a coin deserves professional grading before a sale decision is made.
The same logic applies to designer jewelry and antique silverware. A Georg Jensen piece or a signed Art Deco bracelet has resale value that far exceeds its metal content. Selling it as scrap would be a significant loss.
Common Misconceptions About Selling Precious Metals
“Hallmarks mean the value is set.” Hallmarks suggest purity. Actual value depends on current spot prices, buyer margins, and whether the item has collector appeal beyond metal content.
“All gold buyers pay the same.” They do not. Overhead, refining relationships, expertise, and business model all affect what a buyer can offer. A specialist bullion dealer typically offers more than a pawn shop for the same item.
“Pawn shops are always a bad deal.” Not always, but they are rarely the best deal for precious metals. Their business model covers a wide range of goods, and precious metals expertise is not always deep.
“Broken jewelry is just scrap.” Sometimes. But a broken Tiffany bracelet or a damaged vintage piece from a known maker may have significant resale value. Get it appraised before accepting a scrap offer.
“Silver is silver.” Sterling jewelry, 90% coin silver, and .999 bullion are three different products with three different purity levels and three different prices per gram. Know which you have.
Why Accurate Precious Metals Is the Right Choice
Accurate Precious Metals has been operating since 2012 and has earned more than 1,000 five-star reviews from customers across the country. The team is based in Salem, Oregon, but the business serves sellers nationwide through a streamlined mail-in service that includes free insured shipping and fast payment.
Unlike a pawn shop, Accurate Precious Metals is a dedicated precious metals dealer. The inventory spans gold, silver, platinum, and palladium in coin, bar, and bullion form, plus diamonds and jewelry. Pricing reflects live spot prices, so offers are competitive rather than based on stale or arbitrary numbers.
For sellers, that means whether you are bringing in a solid gold piece with a recognized hallmark or shipping in a mixed lot of estate jewelry from another state, you are dealing with a team that understands the difference between melt value and collector value – and prices accordingly.
The NGC Authorized Dealer status is particularly important for coin sellers. If you have coins that might be worth grading before sale, the team can walk you through that process rather than defaulting to a melt offer.
Local customers in Salem and the surrounding area can visit in person for same-day evaluation and payment. Sellers anywhere in the US can use the mail-in program – packaging materials, insured shipping, and GIA-certified appraisals are all part of the process. Questions? Call (503) 400-5608 or visit AccuratePMR.com.
ℹ️ Info: Whether you are local to Salem or shipping from the other side of the country, Accurate Precious Metals offers competitive prices based on current spot prices. Visit in person or start your mail-in at AccuratePMR.com/we-buy/mail-in-your-jewelry.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a hallmark on gold or silver jewelry?
A hallmark is a stamp that indicates the metal's purity, maker, or country of origin. Common gold hallmarks include 10K, 14K, 18K, and 585 or 750 in European notation. Silver hallmarks include 925, Sterling, and .999. These marks help buyers estimate purity quickly, but reputable dealers always confirm with testing before making an offer.
How do I know if my gold jewelry is real before selling it?
Look for a karat stamp – 10K, 14K, 18K, or a numeric equivalent like 585 or 750. If no mark is visible, a buyer can test the metal using acid testing, electronic testing, or XRF analysis. You do not need to test it yourself before visiting a dealer.
What is melt value and how is it calculated?
Melt value is the dollar value of the pure metal content in an item, based on current spot prices and the item's purity. The formula is: spot price x troy ounces x purity. At the time of writing, gold is approximately $4,353/oz and silver approximately $72/oz. Use those as your baseline.
Should I sell my coins as scrap or as collectibles?
Always get a coin evaluated by a coin specialist before accepting a scrap offer. Many coins carry numismatic value well above their metal content, especially key dates, proof coins, and graded examples. Selling a rare coin as scrap means accepting the lowest possible price.
Can I sell gold and silver if I am not in Salem, Oregon?
Yes. Accurate Precious Metals offers a nationwide mail-in service with free insured shipping. You can ship items from anywhere in the US, receive a competitive offer based on current spot prices, and get paid quickly. Visit AccuratePMR.com to request a mail-in kit.
Do I need to bring identification to sell gold or silver?
Many states and local ordinances require buyers to record identification for precious metals purchases. Bring a government-issued photo ID when visiting any dealer in person to ensure the transaction can be completed without delay.
What is the difference between a bullion dealer and a pawn shop?
A bullion dealer specializes in precious metals – gold, silver, platinum, and related items – and typically has deeper expertise and better pricing infrastructure than a pawn shop. Pawn shops deal in a wide range of goods and may not have the tools or knowledge to accurately assess precious metals or recognize collectible value.
Make the smart choice — invest with Accurate Precious Metals
Whether you are buying bullion for the first time or adding to a long-term position, our team offers expert guidance, transparent pricing, and a reliable buyback program.
