This content is for educational purposes only and is not financial or investment advice. Precious metals prices fluctuate; past performance does not guarantee future results. Consult a qualified professional before making investment decisions.
Tap the image to enlarge and zoom.Hover to magnify, or click to open full screen.
Every single 1823 Capped Bust dime ever struck carries a hidden secret in its date: a small 2 peeking out from under the 3. That makes the 1823 Capped Bust dime one of the most consistent overdates in early U.S. coinage, and it is a coin that rewards collectors who know exactly where to look.
This guide covers what the 1823/2 overdate actually is, how to spot the Large E and Small E reverse varieties, what these dimes are worth today, and how melt value compares to collector value. We will also cover practical steps for buying, grading, and selling one of these coins.
What Is the 1823 Capped Bust Dime?
The 1823 Capped Bust dime is a 10-cent silver coin struck only at the Philadelphia Mint, part of the Capped Bust design used from 1809 to 1837. Every example dated 1823 is technically an 1823/2 overdate, meaning the Mint reused a die originally cut for 1822 and punched a new 3 over the old 2.
This was not a mistake in the modern sense. Die reuse was standard practice in the early 1800s, when hand-cut dies were expensive and slow to produce. The Mint often carried dies over from year to year, correcting the date by hand punch rather than cutting an entirely new die. The result is a permanent, visible trace of the earlier date on nearly every surviving coin.
Total mintage for the year came to 440,000 pieces, all struck as overdates. That single production run makes the 1823/2 a defined type within the broader Capped Bust dime series rather than a rare anomaly buried in a normal date run.
How Do You Identify an 1823/2 Overdate?
You identify the 1823/2 overdate by finding the remnant of the underlying 2 beneath the final 3 in the date, usually visible along the lower right of the digit. This traced-over numeral is the defining feature that separates the 1823 issue from a standard date coin.
Use a loupe or strong raking light angled across the date to catch the shadow of the old digit. On well-worn coins the overdate can be faint, so patience and good lighting matter more than a high-powered scope.
Inspect the date first under 5x to 10x magnification
Look for a partial 2 shape trapped inside or beside the 3
Angle a light source across the surface rather than straight down
Compare against reference photos from a trusted grading resource before assuming a variety
Beyond the date, the reverse legend holds the second layer of identification. Checking the size of the letter E in "STATES" on the reverse tells you which of the two recognized varieties you are holding.
What Are the Large E and Small E Varieties?
The Large E's and Small E's varieties refer to the size of the letter E used in the reverse legend "UNITED STATES OF AMERICA" on the 1823 Capped Bust dime. This is the primary variety split collectors chase within the 1823/2 date.
To tell them apart, focus on the word "STATES." On the Large E variety, the E's are noticeably taller and bolder relative to the surrounding letters. On the Small E variety, the same letters sit smaller and more compact within the legend. Side-by-side comparison photos make the difference much easier to see than trying to judge either variety in isolation.
Because both varieties come from the same mintage of 440,000 coins, distribution between them is not perfectly even, and certain grade and variety combinations command sharply higher prices at auction and in dealer inventory than others.
How Much Is an 1823 Capped Bust Dime Worth?
An 1823 Capped Bust dime is worth anywhere from about $30 in heavily worn condition to several thousand dollars in choice uncirculated grades, with the reverse variety and overall eye appeal shifting the number significantly. Grade drives value far more than the date itself, since every 1823 dime shares the same overdate.
Broad market guides put common circulated grades around $35 to $60, moving up to roughly $450 to $800 for Fine to About Uncirculated pieces. Variety-specific listings for the 1823/2 show a wider spread, from about $121 in lower grades up to $4,114 or more for top examples, depending on which reverse type and how well the coin has survived over two centuries.
Grade Range
Typical Retail Value
Well worn (Good-VG)
$30 to $60
Fine to Very Fine
$100 to $450
Extremely Fine to AU
$450 to $800
Choice AU / Mint State
Several hundred to several thousand
These ranges are guidelines pulled from current market listings, not fixed prices. Two coins in the same numeric grade can sell for very different amounts depending on originality, strike quality, and whether the surfaces show cleaning or doctoring.
How Much Silver Is in an 1823 Capped Bust Dime?
An 1823 Capped Bust dime contains about 0.07234 troy ounces of silver, based on its historical weight of 2.67 grams at 89.24% fineness. At silver's spot price of about $57 an ounce at the time of writing, that works out to a melt value of roughly $4.13.
That number matters for context, not for pricing. Collector demand for this overdate pushes almost every graded or well-preserved example far above its raw silver content. Even a heavily circulated, low-grade piece typically sells for many times its melt value once it is recognized as an 1823/2 variety coin rather than generic scrap silver.
Why Do Collectors Care About This Overdate?
Collectors care about the 1823 Capped Bust dime because it represents an entire year's mintage struck as a single, verifiable overdate, giving the series a built-in variety challenge with real historical weight. It is not a modern novelty; it is a genuine artifact of how the early Mint managed limited die-making capacity.
Every coin from this date shares the 1823/2 overdate, so there is no "normal" version to compete with
The Large E and Small E reverse split gives type collectors a manageable, well-documented variety hunt
Survivors in high grade are scarce relative to the 440,000 original mintage
The coin bridges early American silver coinage with the broader story of die reuse in that era
For collectors building a Capped Bust type set, or working toward a full date-and-variety run, the 1823/2 sits near the top of the list of coins worth studying closely before buying.
What Should You Check Before Buying One?
Before buying an 1823 Capped Bust dime, confirm the overdate is visible, identify the reverse variety, and inspect the surfaces for cleaning or damage that can quietly cut a coin's value in half. Buying by date alone, without looking closely at the actual coin, is the most common mistake new buyers make with early silver.
Buying an 1823/2 Dime Safely
1
Confirm the overdate Use strong light and magnification to verify the 2 under the 3
2
Check the reverse letters Determine Large E or Small E before comparing prices
3
Look for cleaning Unnaturally bright or hairline-scratched surfaces reduce value
4
Compare grade to price guides Match condition, not just the date, to current market ranges
5
Consider third-party grading A professional grading opinion adds buyer confidence for higher-value pieces
If you are unsure how to weigh grade against price, our 1934 Washington Quarter value guide walks through a similar grade-by-grade approach that applies to any pre-1965 silver coin, including Capped Bust dimes.
What Are Common Misconceptions About the 1823 Dime?
The biggest misconception is that some 1823 Capped Bust dimes are "normal dates" while others are overdates. That is false. Every 1823-dated dime from this mintage is struck from the 1823/2 overdate die pairing, so there is no non-overdate version to find.
Another common error is treating the overdate as a mint mistake similar to a modern doubled die or off-center strike. It is not. It is a recognized die variety created through intentional die reuse, a normal part of how the Mint operated with limited resources in the 1820s.
Buyers also sometimes assume silver content sets the price. In reality, the roughly $4 melt value is a tiny fraction of what most 1823/2 dimes sell for, since numismatic demand for the date and its varieties overwhelms bullion pricing except on the most damaged, low-grade examples.
How Does the 1823 Dime Compare to Other Pre-1965 Silver Dimes?
The 1823 Capped Bust dime carries far more collector premium than later pre-1965 silver dimes like Mercury or Roosevelt issues, which typically trade closer to their silver melt value unless they are key dates. Understanding that gap helps set realistic expectations when buying or selling.
Standard 90% silver dimes from the 20th century, including 90% silver Mercury dimes, generally sell only modestly above their silver content unless a specific date or mint mark is scarce. Bulk lots of common-date 90% junk silver dimes are priced almost entirely on their silver weight rather than on any numismatic story. The 1823/2, by contrast, sells on its variety and history first, with silver content playing a minor role.
For a broader look at how dime values have shifted across U.S. history, our dime values guide breaks down the transition from silver to clad coinage and why certain early dates hold a premium that modern dimes never will.
Where Can You Sell an 1823 Capped Bust Dime?
You can sell an 1823 Capped Bust dime to a specialized coin and precious metals dealer either in person or by mail, and choosing a dealer with numismatic experience matters more than choosing the closest option. Pawn shops and general buyers often price by weight alone, which shortchanges a variety coin like this one.
Accurate Precious Metals, based in Salem, Oregon, buys Capped Bust dimes and other early U.S. silver coins with attention to both the metal content and the numismatic value behind them. As an NGC authorized dealer with over a decade in business and more than 1,000 five-star customer reviews, the team looks at grade, variety, and originality before making an offer, not just the silver weight. That approach tends to serve sellers of scarce coins better than a straight melt-based buyer.
If you are local to the Salem area, you can bring your coin in for an in-person look and a same-day offer. If you are anywhere else in the country, Accurate Precious Metals' mail-in service lets you send coins in with free insured shipping and get a fair, competitive offer based on current market conditions. For sellers weighing multiple options, our guide to selling silver coins for cash covers what to expect from the process, whether you are parting with a single rare overdate or a larger group of pre-1965 silver.
Should You Get Your 1823 Dime Professionally Graded?
Yes, if your 1823 Capped Bust dime shows strong detail, original surfaces, or a clearly visible overdate, professional grading is usually worth the cost because it increases buyer confidence and resale liquidity. For lower-grade, heavily worn examples, grading fees may eat into a modest sale price and are less necessary.
A professional grading opinion also settles disputes over the Large E versus Small E variety and confirms the overdate is genuine rather than a die scratch or damage. Accurate Precious Metals works with NGC as an authorized dealer, which gives collectors and sellers a straightforward path to get eligible coins evaluated before selling or adding them to a collection.
Whether you are building a Capped Bust type set, researching a family collection, or simply want a fair, informed offer on a coin you already own, working with a dealer who understands both bullion pricing and numismatic value puts you in a stronger position. For readers exploring more of the Capped Bust series or related early silver denominations, our silver bullion and coin category and our Ultimate Guide to Accurate Precious Metals Investment are good next stops.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is every 1823 Capped Bust dime an overdate?
Yes, the entire 1823 mintage of 440,000 dimes was struck as an 1823/2 overdate, with the 3 punched over an earlier 1822 die.
How do I tell if my 1823 dime is Large E or Small E?
Check the size of the letter E in the word "STATES" on the reverse legend; taller, bolder E's indicate the Large E variety, while smaller, more compact E's mark the Small E variety.
What is an 1823/2 Capped Bust dime worth?
Worn circulated examples often sell for roughly $30 to $450, while higher-grade or scarce-variety pieces can bring several hundred to several thousand dollars depending on condition and certification.
How much silver is in an 1823 dime?
The coin contains about 0.07234 troy ounces of silver, based on a 2.67 gram weight at 89.24% fineness, worth roughly $4.13 at silver's spot price of $57 an ounce at the time of writing.
What is the mint mark on an 1823 Capped Bust dime?
There is no mint mark, since the 1823 issue was struck exclusively at the Philadelphia Mint.
How rare is the 1823 Capped Bust dime?
It is considered a better date within the Capped Bust series, and while circulated examples are attainable, high-grade survivors are scarce relative to the original 440,000 mintage.
Should I clean an old silver dime before selling it?
No, cleaning almost always lowers a coin's value by damaging its original surface, so it is best left as-is for evaluation by a knowledgeable dealer.
Make the smart choice — invest with Accurate Precious Metals
Whether you are buying bullion for the first time or adding to a long-term position, our team offers expert guidance, transparent pricing, and a reliable buyback program.
