This content is for educational purposes only and is not financial or investment advice. Precious metals prices fluctuate; past performance does not guarantee future results. Consult a qualified professional before making investment decisions.
Tap the image to enlarge and zoom.Hover to magnify, or click to open full screen.
If you searched “I buy gold and silver” hoping to find someone who will give you an honest number today, you’re asking the right question at the right time. Gold is trading near $3,995 an ounce and silver near $57 an ounce at the time of writing, and both metals have moved enough this year that old price expectations from a drawer full of jewelry or coins are probably out of date. This guide walks through exactly what a fair offer looks like, how dealers calculate it, and how to protect yourself from lowball quotes.
What “I Buy Gold and Silver” Really Means for a Seller
Every coin shop, pawn shop, and online dealer that advertises “I buy gold and silver” is really offering you one of two things: a price tied to melt value, or a price tied to collector demand. Knowing which one applies to your item is the single biggest factor in whether you walk away with a fair deal.
Bullion coins, bars, and rounds trade close to the spot price with a small premium or discount. Jewelry and scrap gold or silver trade at melt value, meaning the buyer pays for the pure metal content only. Rare or well-preserved collector coins can sell for several times their metal value because collectors pay for history and scarcity, not just weight.
A dealer who understands all three categories, and prices each one correctly, is the kind of buyer worth doing business with.
Spot Price: Your Starting Point for Any Fair Offer
The spot price is the current market price for one troy ounce of pure metal. It updates continuously during trading hours and serves as the baseline every reputable dealer uses to build an offer.
At the time of writing:
Gold (XAU): about $3,995 per ounce
Silver (XAG): about $57 per ounce
Platinum (XPT): about $1,639 per ounce
Palladium (XPD): about $1,266 per ounce
These numbers shift throughout the day, so you don’t need the exact minute-by-minute price. Knowing the general daily range is enough to tell whether an offer is in the ballpark or way off.
A fair buyer will tell you which spot price they used and how they adjusted it for your item’s purity. If a buyer won’t discuss spot price at all, treat that as a warning sign, not a formality.
A Short History of Why People Still Buy Gold and Silver
Gold has functioned as money for thousands of years, from Egyptian and Roman coinage to the gold-backed currencies of the 19th and early 20th centuries. Silver served as the everyday transactional metal for most of human history, circulating in coin form long before paper currency became standard.
The United States tied its dollar to gold for decades until 1933, when redemption of paper currency for gold coin ended domestically. The gold standard was fully abandoned in 1971. Today gold and silver function mainly as investment assets and collectibles rather than daily currency, but that history is exactly why certain coins carry value far beyond their metal content. Collectors still chase rare dates, low mintage runs, and well-preserved surfaces on coins like the 1900 Barber Dime, and that demand can push prices well past melt.
Bullion, Jewelry, and Collector Coins Price Differently
Not every gold or silver item you own gets priced the same way. Understanding which category your item falls into changes what you should expect to hear from a buyer.
Bullion Coins and Bars
Bullion is made to be close to pure metal. A [1 oz Gold Eagle] runs about .9167 fine, while a modern silver coin like the [2025 Silver American Eagle] is .999 fine. Bars are simpler still, stamped with weight and purity, and traded near spot with a modest premium when you buy and a modest discount when you sell.
Jewelry and Scrap Metal
Gold jewelry is commonly 10k, 14k, 18k, or 22k, none of which is pure gold. Silver jewelry is usually marked 925, meaning 92.5% pure. Scrap value is based entirely on the metal content inside the piece, not on the design, the brand stamp, or how the item looks on a hand.
Collector and Numismatic Coins
Rare dates, low mintage numbers, and coins in strong original condition can sell for two, five, or more times their melt value. A dealer who quotes only melt on a coin like a pre-1933 U.S. gold piece is very likely underpaying you. If you think you’re holding something scarce, it’s worth reading up on rare coin investing and scarcity before you accept the first number offered.
How Melt Value Gets Calculated
Melt value is the pure metal value inside your item, and it’s calculated with a simple formula: spot price multiplied by purity multiplied by weight in troy ounces.
Take a 14k gold item. Fourteen karat gold is about 58.5% pure. At a gold spot price of $3,995 an ounce, one full ounce of 14k gold carries a melt value of roughly $2,337 at the time of writing (3,995 x 0.585).
Now take a half-ounce of sterling silver, which is 92.5% pure. At $57 an ounce, that piece is worth about $26.36 in melt value at the time of writing (57 x 0.925 x 0.5).
ℹ️ Info: Use these formulas as a floor, not a final answer. A fair cash offer on jewelry or scrap should land close to this number after a reasonable dealer margin, and a fair offer on bullion should land close to spot with only a small discount.
Step-by-Step: Getting a Fair Offer Today
Whether you’re selling a single ring or a full collection, the process is the same. Work through it before you accept anything.
Getting a Fair Offer
1
Sort your items Separate bullion, jewelry or scrap, and collector coins into groups. Look for hallmarks like 10K, 14K, 925, or 999.
2
Check today’s spot price Confirm the current gold and silver spot price from a reliable source so you know the day’s baseline.
3
Estimate a rough value For scrap or jewelry, calculate melt value using spot x purity x weight. This is your floor, not your target price.
4
Get at least three quotes Contact local shops and online dealers on the same day so quotes are based on similar spot prices.
5
Compare the details Look at percentage of spot offered, payment speed, and how each buyer’s reputation checks out.
6
Finalize with a written offer A trustworthy buyer weighs and tests items in front of you and gives you a written summary before you agree.
When you request quotes, ask each buyer what spot price they used, how they arrived at their number, and how they pay. A dealer who answers clearly and calmly is generally one you can trust. A dealer who dodges the question or pushes you to decide on the spot is one to walk away from.
Local Dealers vs. Mailing In Your Items
Sellers generally choose between visiting a local shop in person or shipping items to a dealer through a mail-in program. Both have real advantages depending on your situation.
Local Visit vs Mail-In Service
Pros
✓ See your items weighed and tested in person
✓ Walk out with payment the same day
✓ Compare several local shops in one afternoon
✓ Mail-in programs often reach a wider pool of buyers
✓ Insured shipping protects your package in transit
Cons
✗ Local percentages of spot can vary widely by shop
✗ Small-town options may be limited
✗ Payment may take a few extra days to process
✗ You don’t watch the testing happen live
If you’re in the Salem, Oregon area, visiting in person lets you watch the entire process, ask questions on the spot, and leave with payment the same day. If you’re anywhere else in the country, a mail-in program with insured shipping and prompt payment removes distance as a barrier entirely. Either path should end with the same thing: a clear, written summary of what you sold and what you were paid.
Common Misconceptions About Selling Gold and Silver
Misconception one: “I should get spot price.” You won’t, and that’s normal. Dealers carry testing, overhead, and refining costs, so a fair offer sits below spot for scrap and jewelry, and close to spot for bullion.
Misconception two: “All gold coins are worth their metal value.” Plenty of coins carry collector premiums well above melt. A dealer offering melt-only pricing on a scarce coin is leaving real money on the table for you to walk away from.
Misconception three: “Cash for gold ads are the best deal.” Many of these ads advertise aggressively but pay a small fraction of spot. Always compare against a specialized dealer before mailing anything to an unfamiliar buyer.
Misconception four: “Jewelry is worth what it looks like.” A heavy 10k ring can be worth more than a delicate 18k piece once weight and purity are factored in. Design and brand don’t move melt value.
Misconception five: “One quote is enough.” Prices vary shop to shop and day to day. Three quotes taken on the same day give you a real basis for comparison.
Practical Tips by Item Type
If you’re selling rare coins, know the date, mint mark, and condition before you call anyone. A coin in strong original condition, especially one considered for grading through services like PCGS or NGC, deserves a specialist buyer rather than a general pawn counter.
If you’re selling jewelry or scrap, sort everything by karat first and weigh it on a calibrated scale if you have access to one. That gives you a rough floor before you ever walk into a shop. If you’d rather learn the full process first, our guide on selling jewelry and diamonds walks through what buyers look for.
If you’re selling bullion, keep original packaging and any paperwork that came with the coin or bar. Compare local and online pricing for anything beyond a coin or two, since larger holdings can shift meaningfully in value between one quote and the next. Products like [Silver Britannia coins] or common silver rounds such as the [Engelhard Prospector round] trade close to spot with a modest premium, so pricing them accurately matters more as quantity grows.
Why Sell to Accurate Precious Metals
Accurate Precious Metals has operated in Salem, Oregon for more than 12 years and has built a base of over 1,000 five-star customer reviews along the way. We are not a pawn shop. We are a specialized precious metals dealer, and that distinction matters when you’re trying to get an accurate read on what your gold or silver is actually worth.
Local sellers can visit our Salem location and watch our team weigh and evaluate items for metal content in person. Sellers anywhere else in the country can use our mail-in service, which includes free insured shipping, careful item review, and fast payment once everything checks out. We buy bullion coins and bars, scrap gold and silver, jewelry in any condition, dental scrap, silverware and flatware, luxury watches, diamonds, and both numismatic and bullion coins. Whatever you’re holding, there’s a good chance it fits into our buying program.
Our online pricing reflects live spot prices, and we offer Gold and Silver IRA services for sellers who want to redirect proceeds into retirement holdings rather than cash out entirely. As an NGC authorized dealer, we also support grading services for collectors who suspect they’re holding something with numismatic value beyond melt. If you want a full sense of our buying and selling programs, our complete guide to Accurate Precious Metals covers the details, and our page on selling your gold or selling silver coins for cash outlines exactly what to expect during the process. Sellers who want to compare options before committing consistently find that our combination of nationwide reach, physical presence, and years of reputation make us the clear standout among local dealers.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if an offer to buy my gold and silver is fair?
Compare it against the current spot price adjusted for your item's purity and weight. A fair offer for jewelry or scrap sits reasonably below that melt value, while bullion should land close to spot with only a small discount.
Do I need to clean my jewelry before selling it?
No. Cleaning won't change the metal content, and dealers evaluate items by weight and purity, not appearance. Focus instead on sorting pieces by karat stamp.
Can I sell gold and silver without a physical scale at home?
Yes. A rough estimate using an online melt value calculator is enough to know if a quoted price is in the right range before you visit or ship items to a dealer.
What's the difference between selling scrap and selling a rare coin?
Scrap is priced on metal content alone. Rare coins can carry collector value well above melt based on date, mintage, and condition, so they deserve evaluation from a specialist rather than a melt-only quote.
Is it better to sell locally or mail in my items?
Local visits let you watch the process and get paid the same day. Mailing in works well if you're outside the seller's area and want access to a wider buying program with insured shipping.
Make the smart choice — invest with Accurate Precious Metals
Whether you are buying bullion for the first time or adding to a long-term position, our team offers expert guidance, transparent pricing, and a reliable buyback program.
