Buffalo Nickel: History, Value, Indian Head Design Insights

APMR Team

April 7, 2025
A logo of accuratepmr, a trusted provider of the best gold ira services.

The Buffalo Nickel, also known as the Indian Head Nickel, is a fascinating piece of American numismatic history. Minted between 1913 and 1938, this five-cent coin features the iconic design by sculptor James Earle Fraser, showcasing the rich heritage of Native Americans and the American bison. This article delves into the history of the Buffalo Nickel, its value in today’s market, and insights into its unique design. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a curious newcomer, understanding the Buffalo Nickel’s significance enhances your appreciation for American coinage and its cultural narratives.

What is the Buffalo Nickel?

The Buffalo Nickel is a five-cent coin that was produced by the United States Mint from 1913 to 1938. It is renowned for its distinct design, which features a Native American on the obverse and an American bison on the reverse. This coin represents a significant era in American history and showcases the artistry of its designer, James Earle Fraser.

The Buffalo Nickel not only serves as a currency denomination but also holds a deep connection to American culture, particularly regarding Native American heritage and wildlife conservation. Collectors and historians alike cherish this coin for its artistic and historical value.

Who Designed the Buffalo Nickel?

The Buffalo Nickel’s design came from the creative mind of James Earle Fraser, an American sculptor who captured the essence of American identity through his work. Fraser’s design was influenced by his experiences and observations of Native American culture, particularly during his visits to the Bronx Zoo, where he studied the American bison.

Fraser’s artistic vision not only created a coin but also a symbol of pride and respect for Native Americans. His work emphasizes the connection between the land and its original inhabitants, making the Buffalo Nickel a significant piece in the realm of American coinage.

What is the History of the Buffalo Nickel?

The history of the Buffalo Nickel begins in the early 20th century when the United States sought to redesign its coinage. The Buffalo Nickel was introduced in 1913, replacing the Liberty Head nickel. The new design aimed to reflect a more inclusive American identity, showcasing both the Native American and the buffalo—two symbols deeply rooted in the country’s past.

The coin faced several challenges during its production, including issues with minting that led to its design being easily worn away. Despite these hurdles, the Buffalo Nickel became a staple in American currency until its discontinuation in 1938, marking an end to an era.

What Are the Key Dates for Buffalo Nickels?

When it comes to coin collecting, key dates hold particular significance, and the Buffalo Nickel series is no exception. Certain years produced coins with lower mintage, making them more valuable to collectors. For instance, the 1913-S Type II Buffalo Nickel is one of the most sought-after coins in the series due to its limited availability.

Other key dates include the 1926-S and 1937-D ‘three-legged’ varieties, which command high premiums in the collector market. Understanding these key dates can significantly impact a collector’s strategy and investment in Buffalo Nickels.

What is the Value of Buffalo Nickels?

The value of Buffalo Nickels varies greatly depending on several factors, including condition, rarity, and demand among collectors. Generally, coins in excellent condition—known as uncirculated or mint state—fetch higher prices than well-worn examples.

What Makes the Buffalo Nickel Unique?

The Buffalo Nickel stands out due to its unique design elements, particularly the depiction of a Native American and the American bison. The obverse features a profile of a Native American, representing a composite of various tribes, rather than a specific individual, which adds to its symbolic nature.

The reverse showcases a bison standing on a raised mound, which Fraser intended to evoke images of the American frontier and the wildlife that roamed it. This combination of artistry and cultural significance sets the Buffalo Nickel apart from other coins in American history.

How to Collect Buffalo Nickels?

Collecting Buffalo Nickels can be an exciting and rewarding hobby for numismatists. Beginners should start by acquiring coins from reputable sources, such as Accurate Precious Metals, which offers a range of Buffalo Nickels at competitive prices. It’s crucial to understand the grading system, as this will affect the value and desirability of the coins in your collection.

Many collectors focus on completing a full set, which includes all the different dates and mintmarks. Others may focus on collecting specific varieties, such as the Type I and Type II Buffalo Nickels, which differ in design details. Joining collector groups or online forums can also provide valuable insights and resources for expanding your collection.

What Are the Design Elements of the Buffalo Nickel?

The design of the Buffalo Nickel incorporates several distinct elements that contribute to its iconic status. The obverse features the head of an Indian, which is characterized by a strong profile and intricate details that showcase Fraser’s skill as a sculptor. The use of the term “Indian Head” to describe the obverse design reflects the cultural significance attached to Native Americans in early 20th-century America.

The reverse displays a bison, a powerful symbol of American heritage. Fraser depicted the bison realistically, capturing its muscular build and unique features. The raised mound beneath the bison serves to elevate the animal, both literally and symbolically, emphasizing its importance in American history.

Why Buy Buffalo Nickels?

Investing in Buffalo Nickels presents a unique opportunity for both collectors and investors. The historical significance, artistic merit, and growing interest in numismatics make these coins a wise addition to any collection. As the market for collectible coins continues to evolve, the value of well-preserved Buffalo Nickels may appreciate over time.

Purchasing Buffalo Nickels from reputable dealers like Accurate Precious Metals ensures that you acquire authentic coins at fair market prices. Accurate’s expertise and commitment to customer service provide peace of mind for both novice and experienced collectors.

FAQ

What is the average price range for Buffalo Nickels?

The price range for Buffalo Nickels varies widely based on condition and rarity. Common dates may cost between $1 to $5, while key dates or coins in mint condition can reach prices from hundreds to thousands of dollars.

How can I tell if my Buffalo Nickel is authentic?

To determine authenticity, collectors should examine the coin for specific design details, weight, and dimensions. Additionally, consulting with a reputable dealer or professional grader can provide assurance of a coin’s authenticity.

Are there any counterfeits of Buffalo Nickels?

Yes, like many collectible coins, Buffalo Nickels can be subject to counterfeiting. Counterfeit coins often lack the fine details found in genuine coins. It’s essential to purchase from reputable dealers and to verify authenticity if you suspect a coin may not be genuine.

What is the best way to store Buffalo Nickels?

Storing Buffalo Nickels properly is crucial to preserving their condition. Use coin holders or albums designed for numismatics to protect the coins from scratches and environmental damage. Avoid storing them in direct sunlight or humid environments.

Where can I sell my Buffalo Nickels?

Collectors looking to sell Buffalo Nickels should consider reputable dealers like Accurate Precious Metals, who offer fair evaluations based on current market conditions. It’s advisable to research and compare offers to ensure you receive the best value for your coins.

Summary of Key Points

  • The Buffalo Nickel, designed by James Earle Fraser, was minted from 1913 to 1938.
  • It features iconic designs of a Native American on the obverse and an American bison on the reverse.
  • Key dates and condition significantly influence the value of Buffalo Nickels.
  • Collectors should purchase from reputable dealers like Accurate Precious Metals to ensure authenticity and fair prices.
  • Proper storage and care are essential for preserving the condition and value of Buffalo Nickels.

Explore more from APMR

Shop Gold

Explore gold coins & bars.

Explore the lowest premiums on gold coins & bars.

Buy 2023 1oz gold eagle coins from accurate precious metals refineries
Shop Silver

Discover silver coins & bars.

Discover silver coins & bars at unmatched premiums.

Buy 2023 1oz silver eagles from accurate precious metals refineries
Special offer