The $2.5 1867 Liberty Head quarter eagle: A numismatic deep dive
Disclaimer
Accurate Precious Metals is not a financial advisor. We encourage everyone to consult a financial advisor or CPA. They can help determine the best investment strategies. Our mission is to provide educational content about precious metals. Accurate Precious Metals is committed to transparency and reliability. They offer top-tier precious metal products and information.
This information is subject to change due to market fluctuations, world events, and factors beyond our control. Additionally, the content may not fully reflect our company’s values, as personnel, staff, and authorship may change over time.
The $2.5 1867 Liberty Head quarter eagle is one of the most historically compelling small gold coins in American numismatics – a tiny 18mm disc that carried real economic weight during the turbulent years of Reconstruction. With a Philadelphia mintage of just 3,200 business strikes and a San Francisco issue of 28,000, this coin sits at a fascinating crossroads between scarcity, historical significance, and rising gold prices. Whether you are building a Liberty Head type set, hunting for undervalued gold, or deciding whether to sell a coin you inherited, this guide gives you the year-specific detail you need.
Unlike our broader guides on maximizing cash or opening collector value for everyday jewelry pieces, this article drills into the 1867 date specifically – its three distinct types, grading realities, auction market behavior, and what separates a $1,000 coin from a $15,000 one. Gold currently trades near $4,750 per ounce, which puts the raw melt value of this coin at roughly $574. But numismatic premiums push most examples well past that floor, sometimes by a factor of 30 or more.
Historical Background: A Coin Born from Reconstruction and Gold Rush Wealth
Christian Gobrecht designed the Liberty Head quarter eagle series in 1840. The obverse shows Liberty in profile wearing a coronet inscribed “LIBERTY,” surrounded by 13 stars. The reverse features a heraldic eagle clutching arrows and an olive branch, with “$2 1/2” beneath the eagle’s tail and a mintmark – if present – tucked just below.
By 1867, the United States was two years past Lincoln’s assassination and deep into Reconstruction. Gold had been hoarded throughout the Civil War, and Western mining operations were flooding the San Francisco Mint with raw metal. The Philadelphia Mint, meanwhile, struck far fewer coins – partly because gold demand in the East was met by larger denominations and paper currency.
These quarter eagles were legal tender worth a day’s wages for many workers. At 4.18 grams and 18mm across, they were smaller than a modern dime in diameter. That small size made them easy to lose, melt, or wear smooth – which is precisely why so few survive in collectible condition today.
The California Gold Rush had opened the San Francisco Mint in 1854, and by 1867 that facility was the workhorse of Western gold coinage. The 1867-S reflects that industrial-scale output, while the Philadelphia issue reflects a quieter, almost incidental production run that has become a prized rarity.
The Three Types of the $2.5 1867 Liberty Head Quarter Eagle
Every collector needs to understand that “1867 quarter eagle” is not a single coin. Three distinct types exist, and they differ dramatically in rarity, value, and collector demand.
1867 Philadelphia (No Mintmark)
This is the key date of the trio. The Philadelphia Mint struck just 3,200 business strikes, and today only an estimated 55 to 65 examples survive. Most grade AU53 to AU58 – lightly circulated but never heavily worn, suggesting they spent limited time in commerce before being saved or stored. Uncirculated examples number fewer than five known. CAC has approved only six total across all grades, a proof to how few meet strict quality standards even among survivors.
Philadelphia strikes from this era often show semi-prooflike fields – a mirror-like reflectivity caused by early-die polish – paired with a rose or orange-gold tone. The surfaces, however, tend to be marked and abraded, which is typical for coins that passed through counting machines or bank vaults. Finding a clean, original-skin example is genuinely difficult.
1867-S San Francisco
The San Francisco issue had a mintage of 28,000, making it far more available in circulated grades. Dealers regularly list VF and EF examples in the $1,200 to $1,500 range. However, mint-state survivors are scarce – population reports at major grading services show thin representation above MS62, and high-grade gems are essentially nonexistent.
The 1867-S is the entry point for most Liberty Head set builders. It gives you the date at a manageable price and lets you upgrade to the Philadelphia coin later if budget allows. The “S” mintmark sits on the reverse below the eagle, small and left-aligned. Always confirm its presence before purchasing – a removed mintmark can turn an S-mint into a fake no-mintmark coin.
1867 Proof
Philadelphia also produced a small number of proof strikes for dignitaries and collectors. Mintage estimates range from roughly 25 to 50 coins. These feature mirror-like fields, sharp design detail, and sometimes cameo contrast between the frosted devices and reflective background. Proofs were never intended for circulation. Starting prices for problem-free examples run $10,000 and up, with gem specimens potentially reaching six figures at major auction.
| Type | Mintage | Estimated Survivors | Typical Grade Range | Entry Price (Approx.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1867 Philadelphia | 3,200 | 55-65 | AU53-AU58 | $5,000+ |
| 1867-S San Francisco | 28,000 | Higher, MS rare | VF-EF common | $1,000-$1,500 |
| 1867 Proof | ~25-50 | Very few | PR60-PR65 | $10,000+ |
Grading the 1867 Liberty Head Quarter Eagle: What to Look For
Grading determines value more than almost any other factor with this coin. The Sheldon scale runs from 1 to 70. Here is what to examine on each side.
On the obverse, Liberty’s hair curls above the ear show wear first. In EF40, those curls are distinct but slightly flat at the high points. By AU55, the curls remain sharp with only light friction on the cheekbone. In mint state, the full hair detail is crisp, and Liberty’s eye appears as a sharp, defined point – collectors often describe a well-struck MS65 as having Liberty’s eye “alive” under a loupe.
On the reverse, the eagle’s breast feathers and the top of the wings wear first. In VF grades, the feathers merge into flat planes. EF shows most feathers distinct but slightly soft. AU and above retain sharp feather separation. The “$2 1/2” denomination below the eagle should be fully bold even in circulated grades – if it is weak, the coin may have been cleaned or altered.
Third-party grading through PCGS or NGC is strongly recommended for any 1867 quarter eagle. The total PCGS population for the Philadelphia issue sits below 100 graded coins across all grades. NGC numbers are similarly thin. A CAC gold sticker – awarded when a submission coin is considered solid for its grade – can boost realized prices by 20 to 50 percent or more at auction.
Value and Pricing: Where the $2.5 1867 Liberty Head Quarter Eagle Stands Today
With gold near $4,750 per ounce, the melt value of a 1867 quarter eagle sits at approximately $574 (0.12094 troy ounces of pure gold x $4,750). That is your absolute floor – no collector-grade example should sell for less.
In practice, numismatic premiums push prices far higher.
For the 1867 Philadelphia issue:
- Circulated VF/EF examples: $1,750 and up
- AU50-AU58: $5,000-$15,000 depending on strike quality and eye appeal
- Mint state (MS60+): $20,000 or more, with very few available at any price
- CAC-approved EF45: auction results suggest $5,000-$6,000 range
For the 1867-S:
PCGS & NGC Coin Verification – Accurate Precious Metals Refineries
- Average circulated: $1,000-$1,250
- VF/EF: $1,250-$1,500
- MS60-MS62: $5,000-$8,000
- MS63 and above: $15,000-$20,000+, rarely offered
For Proofs: Start at $10,000 for problem-free lower-grade examples; gem cameo proofs have reached six figures.
The broader gold market matters too. When spot gold rises, melt floors rise with it, which compresses the percentage premium collectors pay – but it also tends to draw more buyers into the rare coin market, pushing numismatic prices up alongside. The 1867 Philadelphia, with its extreme rarity, has historically appreciated faster than bullion during gold bull markets.
Comparing the 1867 to Neighboring Dates
Context matters when building a Liberty Head set. How does the 1867 stack up against adjacent years?
| Date | Mint | Business Strike Mintage | Relative Rarity | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1866 | Philadelphia | 3,110 | Rarer than 1867 | Lower mintage, similarly scarce survivors |
| 1867 | Philadelphia | 3,200 | Very Rare | Key date |
| 1867 | San Francisco | 28,000 | Scarce in MS | Affordable in circulated grades |
| 1868 | Philadelphia | 3,600 | Rare | Slightly higher mintage but similar survival |
| 1868 | San Francisco | 34,000 | Scarce in MS | More available than 1867-S in all grades |
The 1866 Philadelphia is technically rarer by mintage, but the 1867 Philly is considered equally challenging to locate in AU and above due to attrition patterns. Collectors building date sets often treat 1866-1868 Philadelphia issues as a trio of key dates requiring patience and budget.
Buying Strategy: Building a Liberty Head Quarter Eagle Set
A Liberty Head type set – one example of each major design – requires only a single quarter eagle. A date set, however, demands one coin per year from 1840 through 1907, and the 1867 Philadelphia is among the hardest to acquire.
Start with the 1867-S in VF or EF. It gives you the date at $1,000-$1,500 and lets you study the design without overextending.
Get it graded by PCGS or NGC if it is raw. An ungraded coin is harder to sell and easier to misrepresent. Weight should be 4.18 grams; edge reeding should be sharp and even.
Track auction archives at Stack’s Bowers and Heritage for 1867 Philadelphia examples. These appear infrequently – sometimes only once or twice per year at major sales.
Set a budget ceiling before bidding. Auction fever is real. Know your grade target and maximum price before the gavel drops.
Upgrade the S-mint to Philadelphia when the right coin appears. Prioritize original skin, even if the grade is lower – an original AU50 often outperforms a cleaned AU58 at resale.
Avoid purchasing ungraded 1867 quarter eagles on general online marketplaces. Counterfeits exist – gold-plated base metal coins can mimic the weight and appearance closely enough to fool casual buyers. Always verify weight (4.18 grams) and consider XRF analysis to assess metal content if you are buying raw.
Common Misconceptions About the 1867 Quarter Eagle
A few myths circulate among newer collectors that are worth addressing directly.
“The S-mint makes this date common.” The 1867-S mintage of 28,000 sounds large compared to the Philadelphia issue, but it is tiny by modern standards. High-grade S-mint examples are genuinely scarce, and the Philadelphia coin is outright rare at any grade.
“Melt value sets the price floor for everything.” For common bullion coins, yes. For a coin with 55 known survivors, collector demand sets the price. The melt floor of $574 is almost irrelevant when an AU55 example trades at $10,000 or more.
“It looks like a half eagle or eagle.” The quarter eagle is 18mm across – smaller than a modern dime in diameter, though thicker. New collectors sometimes confuse it with the $5 half eagle or $10 eagle, both of which are larger. Always confirm the denomination on the reverse.
“Proofs are common because they were made for collectors.” Proof mintages for 1867 quarter eagles are estimated at 25 to 50 coins total. They are among the rarest proof gold issues of the Reconstruction era.
“Any 1867 quarter eagle is automatically worth thousands.” Condition is everything. A heavily cleaned, problem-coin example in VF details may sell for little more than melt. A problem-free AU58 is a genuinely rare object worth serious money. The difference is in the surfaces.
Selling Your $2.5 1867 Liberty Head Quarter Eagle
If you own one of these coins and are considering selling, the approach matters as much as the coin itself. This is where understanding the best place to sell jewelry and rare gold coins becomes critical – and where a specialized precious metals dealer outperforms a general pawn shop or online marketplace every time.
Pawn shops for jewelry and coins typically offer 40 to 60 cents on the dollar because they need margin for resale and lack the numismatic expertise to accurately price rare coins. General online platforms expose you to fraud risk and fee structures that erode your return. Auction consignment through Stack’s Bowers or Heritage reaches the right buyers but carries 10 to 20 percent seller fees and can take months.
For collectors looking for a faster, transparent process, selling to a specialized dealer is often the most practical option. Accurate Precious Metals, based in Salem, Oregon, has been buying gold coins, bullion, jewelry, and numismatic pieces for over 12 years. With more than 1,000 five-star reviews and competitive pricing tied to live spot rates, it operates as a full-service precious metals dealer – not a pawn shop.
Local sellers in the Pacific Northwest can visit the Salem location in person for a same-day evaluation. Customers anywhere in the United States can use the mail-in service – Accurate Precious Metals provides insured shipping, evaluates your coin through a trusted and transparent process, and pays promptly. The team can assess metal content via XRF analysis and examine coins for numismatic value, ensuring you are not leaving money on the table by selling a rare 1867 Philadelphia as scrap.
For a broader look at your options when selling gold coins or jewelry, the best place to sell jewelry depends on what you own, how quickly you need payment, and whether you want maximum numismatic value or fast liquidity. Accurate Precious Metals offers both paths.
Storage, Insurance, and Long-Term Care
Once you own a 1867 quarter eagle, protect it properly. These coins are small and easy to damage.
- Store in an airtight capsule or PCGS/NGC slab – never in PVC flips, which off-gas chemicals that damage gold surfaces over time.
- Keep humidity below 50 percent. A small silica gel packet in your storage box is sufficient for most home environments.
- Insure for full replacement value, not just melt. A standard homeowner’s policy often caps collectibles coverage at $1,000-$2,000. A scheduled rider or dedicated collectibles policy covers the numismatic premium.
- Handle by the edges only, and never without clean cotton gloves. Fingerprints leave acidic oils that etch coin surfaces over years.
- Photograph your coin in high resolution before storing. Document the grade, any certification number, and purchase price for insurance and estate purposes.
Why Accurate Precious Metals Is the Right Partner for Rare Gold Coins
Accurate Precious Metals is not a generalist buyer. The company specializes in precious metals – gold, silver, platinum, palladium – in every form: bullion bars, numismatic coins, jewelry, scrap, and more. As an NGC Authorized Dealer, Accurate Precious Metals has direct access to grading services, which matters when you are buying or selling a coin as significant as the 1867 Liberty Head quarter eagle.
The nationwide reach sets it apart from local coin shops that serve only walk-in customers. Whether you are in Oregon, Texas, or New York, you can ship your coin securely and receive a competitive offer based on current spot prices and honest numismatic assessment. Pricing is updated in real time to reflect live gold markets – no stale quotes, no lowball offers based on outdated spot data.
For buyers, Accurate Precious Metals carries inventory across gold, silver, platinum, and palladium in coin and bar form, with competitive premiums and insured delivery to your door. For sellers, the process is straightforward: visit in person at the Salem, Oregon location, or use the mail-in service from anywhere in the U.S. Either way, you deal with experienced professionals who understand the difference between a common bullion coin and a key-date rarity like the 1867 Philadelphia quarter eagle.
Call (503) 400-5608 or visit AccuratePMR.com to get started.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the melt value of a $2.5 1867 Liberty Head quarter eagle?
At current gold prices near $4,750 per ounce, the melt value is approximately $574. The coin contains 0.12094 troy ounces of pure gold (90% gold composition, 4.18 grams total weight).
How do I tell the difference between the 1867 Philadelphia and 1867-S?
Check the reverse below the eagle's tail. The San Francisco issue has a small "S" mintmark. The Philadelphia issue has no mintmark. Both look identical otherwise, so examine the reverse carefully under magnification.
Is the 1867 quarter eagle a good investment?
Rare coins can appreciate over time, but past performance does not predict future results. The 1867 Philadelphia has a strong rarity argument due to its low survival population. However, Accurate Precious Metals does not provide financial or investment advice. Consult a qualified advisor for investment decisions.
Should I get my 1867 quarter eagle graded before selling?
For the Philadelphia issue especially, yes. A PCGS or NGC grade gives buyers confidence and typically increases realized prices. For heavily worn or problem coins, grading costs may not be justified – ask a specialist first.
Where is the best place to sell a rare gold coin like this?
A specialized precious metals dealer with numismatic knowledge will generally offer a fairer price than a pawn shop or general online marketplace. Accurate Precious Metals buys coins in any condition. Local sellers can visit the Salem, Oregon location; anyone in the U.S. can use the mail-in service.
How many 1867 Philadelphia quarter eagles exist today?
Estimates from major grading services and dealer population reports suggest 55 to 65 surviving examples across all grades. Uncirculated examples number fewer than five known.
What grades are most common for the 1867 Philadelphia issue?
Most survivors grade AU53 to AU58 – lightly circulated but not heavily worn. This suggests limited time in commerce before being saved or stored. Coins below AU50 are uncommon; mint-state examples are extremely rare.
Sources
- AH Coin Co – 1867 Liberty Head Quarter Eagle Product Listing
- NGC Coin Explorer – 1867-S $2.50 Liberty Head Quarter Eagle
- USA Coin Book – 1867-S Coronet Head Gold Quarter Eagle
- Rare Gold Coins Blog – The 1867 Quarter Eagle
- PCGS CoinFacts – 1867 $2.50 Liberty Head Quarter Eagle
- Stack's Bowers – 1867 Proof Liberty Head Quarter Eagle
